Print Post Print Post

Why Permanent Factions Are A Fallacy

Written by | April 2nd, 2011

In George Washington’s Farewell Address – among the many insightful topics that he covered, his warning of the dangers of forming political parties, in our country, were, perhaps, his most brilliant words of all.

I’m sure there are many definitions of faction; but, when I think of political factions, I think of it as any like-minded group of voters, or elected officials, trying to infiltrate, or influence, our Government, laws, Constitution etc.

As George Washington, astutely, pointed out, the formation of factions, and allegiances, among several like-minded individuals, is, indeed, consistent with human-nature. However, in my humble opinion, they also defy human-nature. For example, we are individuals; and, as individuals, we don’t generally appreciate being controlled, or told to walk lockstep with a certain ideology; yet, we see this in so many facets of our lives, and political system –

For example, there are labor unions, who bond together, and influence political outcomes, in order to advance their agendas. However, the presumption is, that the labor union bosses can take dues, paid by individuals, and throw them into a political party – regardless if a particular member belongs to that party or not. Therefore, in the name of job security, perhaps, some are willing to sell out some other values, and walk lockstep with the demands of these labor union bosses, but, I, and I’m sure, others, would not be able to do so.

Then, there is, perhaps, the two most powerful unions of all – they are called The Democrat and Republican Parties. For years, we have been led to believe that these two parties are our Government; and, if we don’t vote for one of these two parties, then our voice has very little chance of being heard. While there may be some truth to that, I still believe, that, if a vast majority of the American population registered to Independents, then we would be a nation of individual voters, again, and not a nation of Republicans and Democrats, being led by the party platform of the day.

The truth is, when our Constitution was written, political parties were not even anticipated in The Constitutional Convention, and, therefore, we had a Constitution that presumed that we would have one political body, in Congress, and a nation of independent Americans – who would elect those who best represented their views. And, over the last few years – as many Americans have become acutely aware of, neither party really pays attention to the 17 specific, limited, and Enumerated Powers, that were given to Congress, by our Founders. Therefore, we are constitutionally electing our Government, but, as far as the laws passed, and the powers assumed, we most certainly do not have The Federal Government that our Founders envisioned; and, which was promised to our nation, by our Founders.

If there were a way to return to the original intents of our Founders, I have no doubt, that, within those 17 Enumerated Powers, we would have plenty of room for different points of view, and opinions. Speaking for myself, I don’t agree, fully, with either The Democrat or Republican Parties. For example, there are some in The Democrat Party who believe, we should only go to war when we are attacked, or in eminent danger of an attack – I happen to fully agree with that. And, conversely, most Republicans have a free-market view of economics, which I also agree with. If you were to take both of these views, you would find that, both are totally consistent with the original intents of our Constitution; however, those views are split into different (factions) parties, and, are not consistent with all members of each party.

These are but a few examples of why I have come to the conclusion that, factions and parties are merely a smoke-screen. They give a perception that they are acting in your best interest, but that is usually operating under the presumption that they always know what is in your best interest. I truly believe that, our Constitution was created for a nation of independent ‘individuals;’  while parties, when formed, treated people with a ‘collectivist’ mentality, in order to further and advance ideologies outside of the scope of our Founders’ original intentions.

Therefore, in my humble opinion, while it may be natural for people to create factions, I truly believe, that, ‘temporary’ factions, made up of interested individuals, in order to advance a specific agenda, or piece of legislation, is much more practical; and, consistent with human-nature.

Like/Follow us
on Facebook

2 thoughts on “Why Permanent Factions Are A Fallacy

  1. Pingback: Why Permanent Factions Are A Fallacy: | MibsBlog

  2. Pingback: The Milquetoast « Precipii's Weblog

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Connect with Facebook